— Just Miscellany — +Addenda

---------------------------------------------------

On the bright side:  I had figured out a somewhat cumbersome, convoluted way of viewing tweets on Twitter without having an account there, but a reader (thank you) sent me a simpler means of doing so, so now I can check on @ibwo_discourse or anyone else when I wish.

Matt Courtman will be holding another monthly (free) Zoom meeting this coming Monday night at 7:30 EDT.

Someone recently asked on Facebook if there’d been much searching in Western Tennessee (and specifically bringing up the Chickasaw Wildlife Refuge). Historically, there were no confirmed reports of Ivory-bills in TN., but in their 2007 report, USFWS did mention 4 areas of the state of possible interest (all in the far west, bordering Arkansas): certain parts along the Hatchie River, Meeman Shelby State Park, Reelfoot Lake area, and yes, the Chickasaw National Refuge. I’ve often cited Bill Pulliam’s enticing reports of possible IBWO at the Moss Island Refuge (which seems on the smallish size, but is close to the larger Chickasaw Refuge). His main posts are HERE and HERE. I could never tell for sure if Bill was toying with his readers over Moss Island, since he never returned for more extensive searching (perhaps? hindered by money and time), but as I’ve reported here before, when I once specifically pressed him if he seriously believed Ivory-billed Woodpeckers resided there, he simply said that IF they did they deserved to be left alone, having survived this long on their own [he didn't particularly encourage folks to go look there, but nor discourage them]. In any event I know of no more recent searches/encounters with IBWO in these areas in subsequent years. BUT yes, western TN., as well as slivers of southeast Missouri and southern Illinois interest me, specifically because of the scarcity of searching ever done there (and a few oddball reports) versus prominently mentioned areas (where more claims come from, but followup searches mostly fail over and over).

As a sidenote will just mention that author Sam Keen, in one of his books, tells the story of growing up around Pikeville, TN. in 1942 (much farther to the east in Tennessee) and as a young birdwatcher being told that a locally shot bird is an Ivory-bill (which he buries) — he admits it was surely more likely a Pileated, but still is haunted a bit all these years later by what the grownups, probably not credibly, insisted at the time.

All of which reminds me a tad of how in philosophy or logic they talk about “necessary and sufficient” conditions for a statement to be true. These days I keep looking for Ivory-bill evidence that is “significant and credible.” Evidence sometimes floats around that might be significant if only one could vouch for its credibility & accuracy… and vice-versa, there are sometimes assertions made which are credible, but which are more rehash or repetition than truly new or significant. Getting “significant and credible” together is a bit of a challenge :(

Otherwise, from the Dept. of Marching-Around-In-Circles I see this discounted photo from almost 20 years ago re-surfaced... yet... again... on YouTube last week; I guess the creator can take pride in the staying-power of his handiwork. Oy:

...and finally, to go from the ridiculous to the sublime (or maybe in this case the other way around?), Chuck Hunter recently linked to an article on the "Birds Aren't Real" movement:

https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2024/04/birds-arent-real-gen-z-politics-mcindoe-adam-faze-fifty-stars.html

Chuck calls the article "intriguing" by which I assume he means 'God help us all!'.

(nothing IBWO-related in the piece, except for peoples' apparent love for, or gravitation toward, conspiracy theories)

---------------------------------------------------

ADDENDUM 4/15:

Will just mention that Hannah Hunter, who I previously wrote of for her piece specific to the Ivory-bill, is back with a co-written article on the "audiovisual afterlives" of the IBWO and a mammalian species, the Bucardo:

https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/24694452.2024.2304206

...and now, ADDENDUM to the Addendum:  Hannah is on a new short podcast about the same topic here:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tMWDpLSKIeY

---------------------------------

ADDENDUM 4/19:

A heads-up (especially for any nearby to the locale)… the Pennsylvania Society for Ornithology 2024 Birding Festival will be held in Washington, Pa. from May 31 - June 2:

https://pabirds.org/2024-schedule/

On Saturday, June 1, Steve Latta is scheduled to share the evidence from their Louisiana study and argue for the persistence of the IBWO ”based on a variety of data collected over a 10-yr search period, 2012-2022” 

??? does that mean he’ll have nothing from 2023 (or for that matter 2024) to share; guess we'll find out in a few months.

---------------------------------

-- Eclipse Day --

--------------------------------------------------------

This morning at 11:29am. Joseph Q. Smeddley of Fargo, ND. became the one millionth visitor to this blog, thus winning a 2024 Lamborghini Revuelto! ;)

OK, so ummm that’s not exactly true, but Google does claim 1 million hits here as of a few minutes ago (...though there are so many sock-puppets running loose in IBWO-land these days, the million hits might only represent a couple dozen people! 😳). Anyway, with any luck there may be a clear photo of a living Ivory-bill before we hit the 2 million mark. Maybe...

Otherwise, the day is auspicious of course because of a certain amazing configuration of the Earth, Moon, and Sun forthcoming. How thoroughly unlikely that such a bizarre geometrically-precise arrangement can even occur! (...skeptics might dare even call it impossible ;)). Just a sorta reminder that Nature is full of improbabilities!! 😉

--------------------------------------------------------

— I’m Almost (but not quite) Missing Twitter —

————————————————

I left Twitter months ago when, like so many others, I could no longer stomach Elon’s destruction of the site (actually returned briefly after a month, just for poster @ibwo_discourse, but then left for good again). I do miss the occasional Ivorybill-related tweets. A reader just sent me the below April Fool’s Day post that someone tweeted of our beloved friend s'posedly perched in the Choctawhatchee (nicely-done, and sorry I don’t know who did it to give credit!). I assume tweeter @ibwo_discourse continues covering IBWO foibles/shenanigans -- if so, he (or she) has had a lot of fodder to play with lately. Twitter is also home to a large birding community and thus may yet occasionally have something significant about IBWO posted.

Anyway, Twitter joins Reddit, Quora, Substack, Threads, Surfbirds, and many other forums I just won’t spend much time with, so feel free to pass along anything you catch there and think important (or entertaining) — usually anything significant will meander its way onto Facebook (which I’d also love to drop, but can’t). Sad to say, just not a lot of great substance or significance is being released on the internet as we draw nearer to the close of yet... another... winter... search... season.... a season in which, if the birds survive, the roostholes, nestholes, foraging sites, they used daily for months yet again go undiscovered.

————————————————

— A Li’l History —

--------------------------------------------------- 

I've posted these before, but will do so again — a few of the past Ivory-bill reports for the month of April that preceded our ‘modern’ day circumstance:

April 1924: Arthur Allen locates/photographs a pair of Ivory-bills in central Florida (that were later killed).

April, 1932: Mason Spencer shoots an Ivory-bill in the Singer Tract and delivers it to a game warden to prove that the species which ornithologists believed was long extinct (but La. backwoodsmen knew wasn't) was still around.

April, 1944: Donald Eckelberry views and sketches an Ivory-bill at the Singer Tract, which some consider as the last confirmed sighting of the species in the U.S., following James Tanner's study and reports from same area.

April, 1955: author and past Audubon President John Terres reports having seen 2 Ivory-bills fly over a highway near Homosassa Springs, Fla.

April, 1956: in the press, an Ivory-bill is reportedly shot in North Carolina though no evidence comes forth to support the claim.

April, 1966: an Ivory-bill is reported in the Neches River swamp area of east Texas.

April, 1967: the first of several sightings of Ivory-bills over a couple of years by H.N. Agey and and George Heinzmann in Polk County, Fla.

April, 1985: Dennis Garratt reports an Ivory-bill in Jonathan Dickinson State Park, Fla.

April, 1999: David Kulivan reports 2 Ivory-bills in the Pearl River refuge of southeast La. Followup searches fail to re-locate or confirm, but the stage sets for the current day saga of the Ivory-billed Woodpecker to begin anew.

[over the above time-period there are easily dozens, perhaps hundreds, of other IBWO claims... the above are just some of the more prominent highlights specific to the month of April]

--------------------------------------------------- 

— April Dr-r-r-r-rumroll.... — +Addenda

 ——————————---------------—

“‘Hope’ is the thing with feathers, that perches in the soul”  — Emily Dickinson

One million and counting.... The Google stats I get for this blog seem a bit whacked, but nonetheless, perhaps worth marking the occasion: looks like this month (possibly even this week) the blog will cross over 1 million hits since its inception, almost 19 years ago. That's a LOT of anal-compulsiveness! (just kidding ;)) 

Especially grateful to the intrepid folks who have stuck it out since the very start, through thick-and-thin, through college or kids or divorces or hernia operations, hip replacements, COVID, and a zillion blurry pictures and unresolved debates; through 4 Presidents and 6 Speakers of the House, through the rise of Taylor Swift and pickleball, and the fall of George Santos! Through Seinfeld re-runs, Bitcoin debacles, the mystery of Malaysian airliner MH370, the deaths of Steve Jobs and Robin Williams and near-lynching of Mike Pence, and of course all the USFWS hemming-and-hawing.... yeah, we been through some thangs… zaniness, vitriol, hopes-raised/hopes-dashed, confusion, intrigue... and, well, more-to-come!…. 😮

Waaaay too many people have made contributions to the discussion over the years for me to try to cite them, but will at least acknowledge 3 names whose work/writings have been especially important to me: Bill Pulliam (deceased), Chuck Hunter, Chris Haney (perhaps not coincidentally, Chuck and Chris were both acquaintances of Bill). Thanks also to those who've quietly helped behind-the-scenes with miscellaneous things over the years, and who need to remain anonymous (you know who you are). And, whether we agree or disagree on specific matters, thanks finally to all who sincerely try to understand the plight of this iconic species and inspire others to do so as well! 

Meanwhile, early on, an experienced British birder labelled those of us who pushed the “Ivory-bills persist” storyline, “stringers,” for endlessly stringing people along — and that was in the early years; he must reeeeally be super annoyed with me by now, all these years later! Keep on reading, and I guess I’ll keep on annoying ;)) 

——————-----------------—————

ADDENDUM 4/2:

Dwight Norris has a longish summary post for his IBWO Facebook group musing about where we’re at after 80 years of Ivory-bill searching:

https://www.facebook.com/groups/179784035376368/permalink/7671707159517314/

…he also muses a bit about the Saluda, SC. claims, including a notion that it could be a case of the principal on-site reporter involved basically doing a dissertation on human gullibility — that was actually a thought I'd had early on, but after investigation and for too many reasons to explain, dropped from consideration (...IF that actually turned out to be true, I hope his professor/advisor at least awards him an "E" for Effort).

Anyway, I suspect Dwight’s post might stir a flurry of thoughts/responses, so maybe take a gander at it and any followup.

------------------------------

Addendum, to the Addendum:

At the moment there are 55 comments to Dwight’s post, causing him to further elaborate now with a 2nd separate posting:

https://www.facebook.com/groups/179784035376368/permalink/7675402589147771/

…not sure how long this might drag out and I had hoped not to spend more time on what has been one of the most embarrassing episodes of many embarrassing episodes in the IBWO saga (…so I won't say much here, but might continue to link to discussions elsewhere) …btw, John Williams’ FB page, if you care to visit, is here:

https://www.facebook.com/john.d.williams.503

 …and includes links to a couple of his prior non-IBWO blogs:

https://motionhealth.blogspot.com

https://bestdriver.blogspot.com

---------------------------------------

-- $$$$ --

---------------------------------------------------

In the last couple months 2 people have emailed me asking about the monetary reward for finding IBWOs… soooo, I imagine others exist with the same basic question...

The original Cornell/Nature-Conservancy reward was $50,000 for anyone who could lead biologists to a living Ivory-billed Woodpecker (likely a nest, roosthole, or foraging site) — just sending in nice pics/video is not enough; you must take appropriate people to the bird! I think, but am not absolutely positive, that that reward still stands…?

Currently, Matt Courtman is individually also offering a $12,000 reward to anyone who can lead him to a living IBWO (he’s based in La. but willing to travel elsewhere).

If anyone knows of other active monetary rewards in play or has any other pertinent details, feel free to pass along.

Frankly, as I told both emailers, IF you get great pics and videos of living IBWOs you can likely make more $$$ in the long run off those pics, and storyline, speaking engagements, articles, interviews, possible book, etc. than you’ll get from the offered rewards! Not to mention the sheer reward of making your mark forever in future scientific books/history! ;)

---------------------------------------------------

— Intermission —

——————————--——————

Nothing Ivory-bill today, just some entertainment… Years ago I once started watching some live bird nestcams that quickly became completely addictive! (...so I quit). My favorites were owls, hummingbirds, and European storks, but there are dozens (maybe 100s) of other species available (some are recorded videos of past nestcams, but I most enjoyed the live ones).

So anyway, it’s time for you all to suffer the addiction… you can start with these:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6DdUcz8ZSBY  (Allen's Hummingbird, California; especially superb)

https://www.allaboutbirds.org/cams/barred-owls/#  (Barred Owl)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vYDOcq4FJYE  (storks, Hungary)

[...perhaps interesting to imagine an active IBWO nest finally being found and USFWS putting a remote camera on it for ongoing viewing over the Web, in hopes of satisfying gawkers and dousing any misplaced desires of birders to traipse through swamp and muck looking for it.]

——————————--——————

-- A Li'l Louisiana History --

 ———————-------------—————

I don’t bother passing along a lot of purely historical-related links, but with all the emphasis on Louisiana these days will cite this recent video in tribute to George Lowery:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oBBcM9nLue8

—————-------------———————

— Note —

**************************

 OK, have gone through and deleted a slew of comments (to various posts) that were simply too sophomoric, too uncivil, too un-useful, or too non-credible to keep (it’s a shame this topic always seems to devolve this way)… and have slightly raised the requirements for commenting here (now, you must have a Google acct.), but if that doesn’t raise the level of responses enough I’ll go to full-scale moderation (where comments are not posted until they are approved). For the past several years more readers have sent me messages via email rather than through the comment channel, and I s’pose that is because they don’t want to be subjected to the counter-comments/snark they may experience... but then also, potentially useful discussion is lost.

Was planning to do an “Open Thread” next week (as many blogs do) where folks could discuss or ask about anything IBWO-related that was on their mind, and discuss among themselves, but now feel like that’s not even worth trying for the moment. :((

**************************

-- Duly Noted --

————————————————

On Facebook (few days ago), Fred Virrazzi (…in his inimitable style ;)) offers up a nice, somewhat succinct technical overview of IBWO wing-beat arguments/data here:

https://www.facebook.com/groups/ivorybillnews/permalink/1772131359973393/

(I won’t vouch for every statement/conclusion Fred makes here, but his thrust is spot on, and the limited data we have from Mexico's Imperial Woodpecker, which he mentions though not spending a lot of time on, has always seemed a real exclamation point to this body of work.)

————————————————

— Blasts From the Past —

-----------------------------------------------------

March 19 (today) is the 16th anniversary of the death of great science-writer/inventor Arthur C. Clarke. Just maybe a good time to recount his “three laws”:

1)  When a distinguished but elderly scientist states that something is possible, he is almost certainly right. When he states that something is impossible, he is very probably wrong.

2)  The only way of discovering the limits of the possible is to venture a little way past them into the impossible.

3)  Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic.

....I can't help but also be reminded of another "Arthur".... philosopher Arthur Schopenhauer's "3 stages of truth" (which used to appear at the head of this blog): 

“All truth passes through three stages: First, it is ridiculed; second, it is violently opposed; and third, it is accepted as self-evident."

-----------------------------------------------------

— An Aside —

 ——————————————--———

Recently, I was a bit surprised to see Dwight Norris, who runs the largest of the various IBWO Facebook groups, and who I don’t often see pass judgment on matters there, end a posting by writing, in reference to the publicized IBWO claims for Saluda, S.C., that he “and many others consider it to clearly be a hoax.” [If you don’t know about the Saluda story I won’t squander time explaining it here, other than to say it is chockfull of problems.]  I assume(?) that Dwight means he believes the first-hand individual making the claims is hoaxing, and not the secondary individual, J.W., who has been the face reporting the story to the public (though at every opportunity that he has had to walk away from the story, he seems to double-down on it, despite some of the published material being retracted). 

I am always on the watch for hoaxes, and don’t rule it out 100% in this case, but my own take has been that this is a more complicated, nuanced circumstance, involving mental/psychological aspects that place it in a different category than simple “hoax” (at least relative to some of the prior straight-out IBWO hoaxes that have transpired). I won’t discuss those nuances, as it would be too speculative and uncertain, but simply submit that “hoax” might not be the best, or most accurate, word for it (...always possible, though, that time will prove me too generous here!).

In any event, I don’t believe Ivorybills are extant in South Carolina… but IF they are, surely not in Saluda County. Evidence (reeeal and definitive evidence) that they persist in Saluda, let alone have been there for over 2 decades, would be perhaps the most incredible story in the entire annals of American ornithology. I’ll gladly settle for an incredible story coming say out of the Atchafalaya or Apalachicola or Pascagoula; no reason to reach for the fantastical.

Speaking of the swamps, for any who've never seen it, will conclude with this old video tribute to our special bird from long-time IBWO searcher/enthusiast Mike Brown:

https://www.facebook.com/groups/179784035376368/permalink/5294385227249531/

———————————--——————